Cleansing oils and balms do the same basic job: they dissolve makeup, sunscreen and oil-soluble residue before rinsing away with water. The useful difference is not which format is universally better, but which one you will massage, emulsify and rinse consistently without over-cleansing.
By Peony Seoul · Editorial update · Our research method
Who this guide is for
Water-resistant sunscreen
Makeup removal
Dry or combination skin
Choosing a first cleanser
A simple routine
Start with dry hands and skin
Massage a small amount over the areas where makeup and sunscreen are concentrated.
Emulsify thoroughly
Add a little water and keep massaging until the oil or balm turns milky.
Second cleanse only when useful
Follow with a gentle water-based cleanser when residue remains; otherwise stop when skin feels clean and comfortable.
Compare fit and trade-offs
| Product | Format | Consider it for | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| beplain Mung Bean Cleansing Oil | Light fluid oil | Makeup, sunscreen and pore-focused first cleansing | Take a little extra time to emulsify around the hairline and sides of the nose for the cleanest rinse. |
| Banila Co Clean It Zero Original Cleansing Balm | Sorbet-to-oil balm | Makeup and water-resistant SPF | The current US Original ingredient list includes fragrance. Check known sensitivities and the exact variant before buying. A first cleanse is optional if your usual cleanser removes what you wore. |
| Beauty of Joseon Green Plum Refreshing Cleanser | Light gel | Balanced and combination skin | The brand says this water-based gel is not designed to remove makeup. Compare a dedicated removal step when needed. |
Peony Seoul shortlist
Research-based options selected for their different formats and routine roles. We have not tested these products hands-on. Shop links on product pages may earn us a commission; see our affiliate disclosure.
beplain
Mung Bean Cleansing Oil
Makeup, sunscreen and pore-focused first cleansingA fluid first-cleanse oil designed to dissolve makeup, resistant sunscreen and oil-based buildup before a water cleanser.
Read the full review →
Banila Co
Clean It Zero Original Cleansing Balm
Makeup and water-resistant SPFA sorbet balm that melts into oil, then emulsifies cleanly for an easy first cleanse.
Read the full review →
Beauty of Joseon
Green Plum Refreshing Cleanser
Balanced and combination skinA mildly acidic gel cleanser with plum water and mung bean extract.
Read the full review →How we compared these products
We compared purpose, texture, skin-type fit, routine compatibility, published formula details, brand standing and access through reputable retailers. The shortlist is organised around useful differences. We do not use commission rates as a selection criterion or treat brand claims as our own test results.
Frequently asked
Is cleansing oil better than cleansing balm?
Neither is automatically better. Oils spread quickly and suit pump-bottle users; balms are less runny and often easier for travel.
Can oily skin use a cleansing oil?
Yes. Rinsability and the full formula matter more than the word oil, though any first cleanser can be skipped when it is unnecessary.
Do I need to double cleanse every night?
No. Double cleansing is useful when one gentle cleanse does not remove makeup or water-resistant sunscreen.
Why does emulsification matter?
Adding water allows the cleansing oils and residue to disperse and rinse more cleanly rather than leaving a heavy film.
Product references and further reading
- beplain Mung Bean Cleansing Oil: brand or retailer product reference
- Banila Co Clean It Zero Original Cleansing Balm: brand or retailer product reference
- Beauty of Joseon Green Plum Refreshing Cleanser: brand or retailer product reference
References identify the product or product line; check the exact regional formula and current pack. Our comparison is an editorial interpretation, not a clinical or laboratory result. Send a correction with the page and source.
Continue your comparison
- Best Korean Hyaluronic Acid Serums for Plump, Hydrated Skin
- Best Korean Sunscreens for Every Day
- Best Korean Moisturizers for Oily Skin